Top Places for the Best Gas Station Pizza in America

The Rise of Gas Station Pizza: Hidden Gems for Road Trippers

When it comes to finding a good slice of pizza, many people think of Italian restaurants, iconic New York City pizzerias, or even their local neighborhood spots. However, one place that often gets overlooked is the gas station. Whether you're on a long road trip or just need a quick bite in the middle of the night, gas station pizza has become a go-to option for many. These convenience stores offer affordable, convenient, and fast meals that can be a lifesaver for hungry travelers.

Gas stations have been slowly improving their food offerings over the years, and pizza is no exception. While not all gas station pizza is created equal, there are several chains that have made a name for themselves with their quality and variety. Here are some of the best places to find a great slice of gas station pizza.

Hunt Brothers Pizza

Hunt Brothers Pizza was founded in 1991 and has since grown to become the largest pizza chain in America, with over 10,000 locations across 30 states. Unlike traditional pizza chains, Hunt Brothers sells its pizzas through convenience stores, making it easily accessible to anyone looking for a quick meal. What sets Hunt Brothers apart is that they offer classic cheese pizza as well as meat and veggie toppings at no extra cost. This makes it a great option for pizza lovers of all kinds.

Many customers praise Hunt Brothers for its flavorful sauce, buttery crust, and fresh appearance. One YouTube creator even called it one of the best gas station pizzas he’s had, highlighting the golden brown crust, plentiful toppings, and low price point. For those looking for a reliable and tasty slice, Hunt Brothers is definitely worth checking out.

Maverik Pizza

Maverik, which operates in over 20 states, started as a small gas station in Wyoming in 1928. Over the years, it has expanded significantly, including a major acquisition in 2023. Maverik's "BonFire" brand offers a variety of food options, including pizza. Some locations feature a BonFire Grill, which allows for made-to-order pizza with a wider selection of toppings.

What makes Maverik pizza stand out is its large slices, crust, and convenience. One Facebook user, who calls himself a "true pizza connoisseur," praised the Meat Mountain pizza as seriously delicious. With a cult following in the mountains, Maverik has earned its spot on the list of must-try gas station pizzas.

Wawa

Although Wawa only operates in 13 states, it is widely loved by locals, especially in college towns. Known for its 24/7 availability, Wawa offers a range of ready-made food, groceries, and drinks. Its pizza menu includes pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and optional garlic-seasoned crusts or sauces like ranch or hot honey.

A YouTube review of the Supreme Pizza praised the garlic crust and generous toppings, while another reviewer gave the pepperoni pie a nine out of 10 rating. Many fans consider Wawa pizza to be one of the best gas station options available.

Casey's

Casey's is often mentioned when people talk about the best gas station pizza. Founded in 1968 in Iowa, the chain now has nearly 3,000 locations across the Southern and Midwestern U.S. Known for its made-from-scratch pies, Casey's has earned a reputation for high-quality, delicious pizza.

Customers consistently praise the sauce-to-crust ratio and the freshness of the slices. The chain also offers a wide range of customizable options, including the popular breakfast pizza. Limited-time offerings like the beer cheese breakfast pizza have also gained attention from fans.

Quik Trip

Quik Trip, based in the Southern U.S., has over 800 locations and is known for its made-to-order food. Alongside other items like soft pretzels and milkshakes, Quik Trip offers a variety of pizza options, including personal and extra-large sizes. The pizza is often described as fresh, crispy, and cheesy, with some fans placing it among their top five pizzas ever.

Personal pizzas are particularly popular due to their convenience and affordability. If you're looking for a quick meal on the go, Quik Trip is a solid choice.

RaceTrac

RaceTrac is a well-known gas station chain in the Southeastern U.S. It started in 1934 and began offering food in 2004. While its pizza menu is limited to cheese, pepperoni, and sausage, some locations may offer additional options like buffalo chicken or breakfast pizza.

RaceTrac is known for its affordability and frequent promotions, such as the buy-one-get-one deal. Fans appreciate the value and taste of its slices, making it a popular choice for those in the region.

Stewart's Shops

Stewart's Shops, based in upstate New York, is a smaller chain that still offers quality food. Known for its dairy products and ice cream, the chain also serves pizza, including cheese, pepperoni, buffalo chicken, and cheesy garlic options. Not all locations have pizza, but those that do are appreciated by locals.

One Reddit user shared how amazing the pizza was after a long hike, highlighting the convenience and quality of Stewart's Shops.

Crosby's

Crosby's, with over 80 locations in New York and Pennsylvania, is another Northeastern favorite. The chain offers a variety of hot food options, including sandwiches, chicken wings, and pizza. Its pizza menu includes classic cheese, meatball, Philly cheesesteak, and veggie options, along with limited-time offerings like the Mafia pizza.

Crosby's is known for its fluffy crust and garlicky base, making it a standout option for gas station pizza lovers.

Pilot Flying J

Pilot Flying J, with over 900 locations across six states, is a popular stop for truckers and road trippers. Its pizza is a main hot food offering, with options including cheese and pepperoni. The dough is hand-braided on-site, giving it a unique texture.

One Facebook user praised the light and airy dough, while others highlighted its affordability and quality. For those in need of a fresh, inexpensive slice, Pilot Flying J is a great option.

Weigel's

Weigel's, with over 80 locations in Eastern Tennessee, is a small but mighty addition to the list. The chain uses only Tennessee milk, providing an authentic local experience. Its pizza options include cheese, pepperoni, sausage, supreme, Hawaiian, and cheeseburger, with limited-time offerings like the garden harvest pizza.

Local reviews have praised Weigel's for its thick crust and affordable pricing, making it a top choice for gas station pizza in the area.

Love's Truck Stops

Love's Travel Stops, with over 600 locations across 42 states, offers pizza through its partnership with Godfather's Pizza. The collaboration began in 1999 and has since expanded to include 75 locations. The pizzas come in large or mini sizes, with options like bacon cheeseburger and hot stuff.

Many customers recall the nostalgic taste of Godfather's, and the on-the-go pies hold up well. If you're on the road, checking if your local Love's has a Godfather's location could be a worthwhile detour.

Speedway

Speedway, a nationwide gas station chain, has roots dating back to the 1950s. While it was acquired by 7-Eleven in 2021, it continues to offer pizza at many locations. Cheese, pepperoni, and breakfast pizza are common options, with some stations featuring expanded menus under the Speedy Café brand.

Customers often call Speedway pizza underrated, with some comparing it favorably to traditional pizza places. A YouTube review of the $5 pizza deal praised its affordability and enjoyment, making it a hidden gem for gas station pizza lovers.