9 Arby's Menu Items That Need a Second Chance and 3 That Should Stay Gone

Arby's and the Return of Forgotten Favorites

Arby's has long been known for its meat-centric menu, but what the fast-food chain can't claim is a consistent lineup of offerings. Since its founding in 1964, the brand has cycled through numerous menu items, many of which have since disappeared. While some of these items have returned after public demand, others remain lost to history. Here are nine discontinued Arby's menu items that fans believe should make a comeback, along with three that are best left in the past.

The Loaded Italian Sandwich: A Fan Favorite That Deserves a Permanent Spot

One of the most beloved items to disappear from the Arby's menu was the Loaded Italian Sandwich. This hearty sub featured pepperoni, salami, capicola, provolone cheese, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato, and red onion on a toasted roll. It gained a loyal following for its bold flavors and unique Italian flair. Its removal in 2021 sparked significant backlash, leading to a Change.org petition that garnered over 2,000 signatures. Despite a limited-time return, fans argue that this sandwich deserves a permanent spot on the menu.

Hushpuppy Fish Strips: A Unique Seafood Offering

In 2022, Arby's introduced Hushpuppy Fish Strips, a daring move into the seafood market. These pollock fish strips were coated in a crispy hushpuppy breading and served with tangy tartar sauce. While initial reviews were mixed, many customers praised the flavor and quality. Fans believed the item had potential and argued it should be brought back as a permanent offering.

Three Pepper Sauce: A Flavorful Condiment That Should Return

The Three Pepper Sauce, known for its spicy yet tangy taste, was another casualty of Arby's menu changes. Made with red bell peppers, jalapeños, black pepper, tomato paste, brown sugar, mustard, vinegar, and spices, this sauce was a fan favorite. Customers lamented its disappearance, suggesting that Arby's could sell bottled versions like its Horsey sauce. With its versatility, the Three Pepper Sauce could enhance any menu item.

The Angus Three Cheese and Bacon Sandwich: A Hearty Classic

For much of the 2010s, the Angus Three Cheese and Bacon Sandwich was a staple at Arby's. Featuring black angus beef, Swiss and cheddar cheese, Parmesan peppercorn ranch sauce, and pepper bacon, this sandwich was a favorite among fans. Although it was eventually discontinued, many believe it should return. Some fans even created petitions and sought copycat recipes, highlighting the strong demand for this classic.

Pizza Sliders: A Nostalgic Treat That Fans Miss

Introduced in 2017, the pizza slider was a unique addition to Arby's value menu. Featuring pepperoni, salami, provolone cheese, and garlic marinara on a toasted bun, this item was popular for its bold flavors and affordable price. When it was removed, fans expressed disappointment, and a Change.org petition gathered over 250 signatures. Many believe it deserves to be brought back.

Southwest Chicken Avocado Wrap: A Spicy Twist on a Classic

In 2021, Arby's introduced the Southwest Chicken Avocado Wrap, featuring chicken, avocado, lettuce, tomato, onion, and chili lime ranch sauce. This wrap offered a spicier option for those who enjoy hotter food. While some criticized the presentation, the flavor was highly praised. Fans argue that this wrap adds variety to the menu and deserves a permanent spot.

Pecan Chicken Salad Sandwich: A Limited-Time Delight

The Pecan Chicken Salad Sandwich was a seasonal favorite, featuring chicken salad with grapes and pecans. Its absence from the menu in 2025 sparked a Change.org petition, with fans expressing their desire for its return. While copycat recipes exist, many believe the original version is irreplaceable.

Chocolate Turnover: A Sweet Nostalgic Treat

The chocolate turnover, a once-popular dessert, disappeared from the menu in 2016. Known for its flaky crust and gooey chocolate filling, it was a favorite among customers. Despite the introduction of other desserts, fans argue that the chocolate turnover should return to satisfy sweet cravings.

Polar Swirl: A Creamy Dessert That Belongs Back on the Menu

In the 1980s, Arby's introduced the Polar Swirl, a creamy shake blended with various candy options. While it was discontinued by the early 2000s, fans still remember its nostalgic appeal. With its unique combination of flavors, the Polar Swirl could fill a niche on the menu and bring back a sense of nostalgia.

Items That Should Stay in the Past

While many items deserve a comeback, there are a few that fans agree should remain in the past. The Loaded Curly Fries, Market Fresh Salads, and the Chicken Club Wrap are among those that didn't resonate well with customers. Their discontinuation was met with little resistance, and fans believe they don't need to return.

Conclusion

Arby's has a rich history of menu innovations, but not all items have stood the test of time. While some items have made a triumphant return, others remain lost to history. As fans continue to voice their preferences, it's clear that certain menu items hold a special place in the hearts of Arby's loyal customers. Whether it's a return of the Loaded Italian Sandwich or the reintroduction of the Polar Swirl, the future of Arby's menu remains an exciting topic for food lovers.