Try These 3 Spooky Netflix Horror Movies Like 'Until Dawn' Now

A New Era of Horror on Netflix

The horror film Until Dawn has made its way to Netflix after originally debuting in theaters earlier this year. Based on the PlayStation 4 game of the same name, the movie takes some creative liberties for the big screen but still delivers a compelling and engaging story with unexpected twists. For fans of Until Dawn, Netflix offers a vast library of horror films that are sure to keep viewers entertained. To help narrow down the options, several platforms have compiled lists of must-watch horror movies that align with the tone and themes of Until Dawn.

8 Must-Watch Horror Movies to Stream Right Now (May 2025)

Us (2019)

Jordan Peele’s second directorial effort, Us, brings fresh and thought-provoking ideas to the horror genre. The film follows Adelaide, played by Lupita Nyong’o, who encounters her doppelgänger, Red, years after a traumatic childhood experience. This encounter leads to a chilling revelation: every person in America has a Tethered counterpart living underground. When these Tethered emerge, they seek to kill their doubles and take over their lives. As Adelaide and her family face the terrifying threat, they realize that the Tethered are everywhere, and their rage is unstoppable. Us is a gripping exploration of identity, fear, and the dark side of human nature.

Talk to Me (2022)

In Talk to Me, a group of teenagers discovers a supernatural hand that allows them to communicate with the dead. What starts as a thrilling party game quickly turns into a dangerous game of survival. The characters learn that each spirit they summon must be released within 90 seconds, or they risk being possessed. When Mia, one of the teens, decides to break the rules to speak with her deceased mother, she sets off a chain of events that puts her and her friends in grave danger. The film is a masterclass in tension and suspense, blending supernatural elements with emotional depth.

Heart Eyes (2025)

Heart Eyes is a psychological horror film that follows Ally McCabe, a woman who believes she is safe from the notorious serial killer known as Heart Eyes. However, her plans change when she kisses her colleague, Jay Simmonds, to provoke her ex-boyfriend. This act catches the attention of the killer, who sees them as his next target. Heart Eyes not only wants to murder the pair but also plans to frame Jay for his crimes. The film is a tense and unpredictable thriller that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats.

These three films offer a variety of horror experiences that will appeal to fans of Until Dawn. Whether it's the psychological depth of Us, the supernatural thrills of Talk to Me, or the intense suspense of Heart Eyes, there’s something for every horror enthusiast. With more titles to explore, Netflix continues to be a go-to destination for fans of the genre.