Sorry, 'Superman'—These 10 Superhero Films Outshine You

A New Era for Superman and the Superhero Genre

Superman has finally made its long-awaited return, marking a promising start to the DC Universe (DCU). Fans have praised James Gunn's film for its creativity, heart, and humor, but despite its success, it is not without flaws. While it is an excellent film, there are several superhero movies that surpass it in various aspects such as writing, storytelling, entertainment value, themes, and critical acclaim.

This list will explore ten notable superhero films that stand out in comparison to Superman. The evaluation will be based on multiple factors, including fan opinion, critical reception, and overall impact on the genre.

Thor: Ragnarok (2017)

Directed by Taika Waititi, this Marvel movie revitalized the Thor franchise and introduced a new level of humor and action. The film follows Thor and Loki as they find themselves on a faraway planet, facing off against their evil sister, Hela. With its colorful aesthetic, comedic moments, and impressive action sequences, Thor: Ragnarok offers a unique blend of silliness and depth. Many fans consider it one of the funniest and most entertaining action movies, making it a strong contender over Superman.

Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox (2013)

Although it is an animated film, Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox is considered one of the best in the DC animated universe. It explores an alternate timeline created by The Flash, where superheroes fight each other. The film adapts one of the best DC Comics stories while adding new dramatic elements. Unlike Superman, which made significant changes to the Man of Steel's lore, this film remains faithful to its source material, offering a compelling narrative and well-developed characters.

Black Panther (2018)

Directed by Ryan Coogler, Black Panther received critical acclaim and was widely recognized for its cultural significance. The film follows T'Challa as he returns to Wakanda to take his place as king. Both Superman and Black Panther deal with the legacy of their heritage, but Black Panther is more polished and meaningful, with a larger cultural impact. It is considered Ryan Coogler’s best work and stands out as a powerful representation of African culture and identity.

Logan (2017)

James Mangold’s Logan is often regarded as one of the best-written superhero films. It follows an aging Wolverine as he helps a young mutant escape from a harsh world. While comparing the end of one universe to the beginning of another is not ideal, both films excel in their own right. Logan is brutal, touching, and action-packed, delivering a focused story that resonates deeply with audiences. It is a classic that sets a high bar for storytelling in the genre.

The Incredibles (2004)

Brad Bird’s The Incredibles is a standout in the superhero genre, offering a fresh take on the traditional superhero narrative. It follows a family of once-great superheroes who must confront their past and re-embrace their powers. This Pixar film is a much-needed family-friendly superhero movie that delivers a wholesome adventure, a meaningful message, and a killer score. It is considered a perfect example of what a superhero film can be.

Avengers: Infinity War (2018)

The Russo brothers’ Avengers: Infinity War is often hailed as the crown jewel of the MCU. It features Thanos attempting to collect all the infinity stones, with Earth's Mightiest Heroes trying to stop him. This film is a cultural phenomenon and cinematic experience that reaches the heights of the superhero genre. While Superman may not be better, it is unrealistic for the DCU to top the MCU’s best movie after one attempt. However, this film set a high standard for future superhero films.

Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018)

Directed by Bob Persichetti, Peter Ramsey, and Rodney Rothman, Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse is a groundbreaking animated film that showcases the spirit of comics through its unique style and animation. It follows Miles Morales and an alternate Peter Parker as they navigate the multiverse. While Superman is fantastic, Into the Spider-Verse is a once-in-a-lifetime film that embodies the essence of comic books, making it a standout in the genre.

The Dark Knight (2008)

Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight is often considered the best superhero movie of all time. It redefined the genre with its serious, dark, and gritty approach. The film follows Batman as he faces a new villain, pushing him to his physical and mental limits. Although it is unfair to compare The Dark Knight and Superman directly, it is inevitable given their status as the best and newest DC movies. The Dark Knight redefined the way DC movies operate, setting a high bar for storytelling and acting.

Guardians of the Galaxy (2014)

Before taking over the DCU, James Gunn directed the best trilogy in the MCU, Guardians of the Galaxy. It follows a group of bounty hunters who discover the true power of a mysterious orb. While Superman may be one of Gunn’s best films, Guardians of the Galaxy is his best. The ensemble cast is well-utilized, and the film tells a riveting sci-fi story filled with humor and emotion. It proves that Gunn can create something truly special when unburdened by the weight of franchise-building.

Superman (1978)

Richard Donner’s original Superman film established the genre and influenced everything that came after. It highlights the destruction of Krypton, Clark Kent’s journey, and his first appearance as Superman. While the newest Superman is considered the best modern version, it does not quite surpass the original. The 1978 film is a legend, with Christopher Reeve embodying the character perfectly. It is a perfect origin story and the definitive version of the character, even if it is difficult to live up to such a legacy.