I Hunted Elk with a Wyoming Outlaw

The Unusual Elk Hunt

The story of “Bandit of the Elk Trail” is a remarkable account of an unusual elk hunt that took place in the June 1936 issue of Outdoor Life. This true tale was written by an Easterner who chose to remain anonymous, using fictional names for all characters and places. The narrative captures the journey of a group of hunters who find themselves in a situation far more dangerous than they anticipated.

As the story begins, the narrator is riding alongside Ross on a rocky trail, with Joe, their guide, leading the way toward the Tetons. Scotty, the cook and wrangler, follows with the pack animals. The atmosphere is tense, as Ross expresses his frustration over the challenges they've faced, including losing horses and failing to locate Gulch Creek. The group is clearly lost, and the situation seems dire.

Joe, the guide, appears to be struggling to navigate the terrain. His confusion is evident as he scans the landscape, trying to find a way back. The narrator, frustrated, insists that they need to set up camp before it gets dark. Despite Joe’s bumbling efforts, the group manages to pitch a tent and start a fire. However, the food supply is dwindling, and the only option left is beans. This sets the stage for the next phase of their journey.

The group had initially planned to enjoy the thrill of the West, but instead, they are met with challenges that test their resolve. Ross had invited the narrator to join him on an elk hunt, drawn by the allure of the Western frontier. However, the reality they face is far from what they expected. They are not only lost but also dealing with a guide who seems to know little about the area.

As the days pass, the group’s situation worsens. They are running low on supplies and must seek help from a local ranch. Upon arriving at the ranch, they encounter Blackie Collins, a man who appears to be more of a threat than a helpful figure. He charges exorbitant prices for food and offers to guide them in exchange for a high fee. Despite the risks, the narrator agrees to hire Blackie, hoping that he can lead them to the elusive elk.

However, Blackie's behavior becomes increasingly suspicious. He seems to be more interested in money than in helping the group. The narrator begins to suspect that there is something wrong with Blackie and his wife, who seem to harbor ill feelings towards them. The tension escalates as the narrator starts to feel threatened by Blackie’s presence.

After several days of fruitless searching, the narrator finally spots a magnificent bull elk. With a mix of excitement and fear, he takes the shot, securing his trophy. But the victory is short-lived, as Blackie’s true intentions are revealed. He demands an exorbitant sum for the services rendered, and the narrator finds himself in a dangerous situation.

In a desperate attempt to escape, the narrator plans to leave under the cover of darkness. He carefully navigates the terrain, avoiding detection by Blackie and his wife. As he makes his way to the corral, he faces numerous obstacles, including the risk of being discovered. Finally, he manages to saddle his horse and escape, leaving behind the dangerous environment.

Upon reaching Rangeville, the narrator shares his story with the baker, who reveals that Blackie Collins was once part of a notorious outlaw gang. The realization hits the narrator that he has been in grave danger throughout the entire trip. The experience leaves him with a deep sense of relief and a newfound appreciation for the dangers of the Western frontier.