After 30 Episodes, 'Criminal Minds: Evolution' Sets the Stage for Spencer Reid's Big Return

A Return to the BAU: The Hopes for Matthew Gray Gubler's Comeback

The latest season of Criminal Minds: Evolution has reignited a sense of hope among fans, particularly those who were deeply affected by the departure of Matthew Gray Gubler’s character, Spencer Reid. Reid left the show at the end of Season 15, and although fans held onto the possibility of his return, it seemed increasingly unlikely. However, the unexpected happened when Gubler made a brief cameo in Season 3, Episode 3. While it was a touching moment—Reid showing up at the funeral of Will (Josh Stewart) to support his best friend J.J. (A.J. Cook)—it fell short of what many fans hoped for. Instead of seeing the enigmatic genius in action, fans were treated to a fleeting appearance with just one line.

This small return, while heartfelt, didn’t satisfy the deep longing for Reid’s presence in the team’s investigations. Fortunately, there are signs that the tides may be shifting. With the recent release of the CBS fall schedule, whispers of a more significant return have begun to circulate. Fans are cautiously optimistic that Gubler could make a more meaningful appearance, not as a mere background figure but as a guest star contributing to the show’s core narrative.

Matthew Gray Gubler’s Current Projects and Potential Opportunities

One of the main reasons Gubler hasn’t returned to Criminal Minds is due to his busy schedule. He has been working on other projects, including his role as the lead in Einstein, another CBS procedural. In this show, he plays the great-grandson of Albert Einstein, a character with a rebellious streak and a unique perspective that mirrors Reid’s genius but with a different personality. Despite the compelling premise, Einstein was delayed from its original 2025-2026 schedule and will now air in the 2026-2027 season. According to CBS Entertainment President Amy Reisenbach, the delay was partly due to the network’s desire to refine the show’s development and ensure its long-term success.

This delay opens up potential opportunities for Gubler to return to Criminal Minds: Evolution in a more substantial way. While a full-time return as a series regular is unlikely, a guest appearance could be a realistic next step. The show has already demonstrated that guest stars can have a lasting impact, as seen with Jill Gideon (Felicity Huffman) in Evolution Season 2. Her limited appearances created a memorable character arc, a dynamic relationship with David Rossi, and contributed significantly to the cases.

The Possibility of a More Meaningful Return

If Gubler were to return, it would need to be in a way that resonates with fans. The ideal scenario would involve him being involved in an investigation rather than a personal subplot. Fans want to see Reid deliver that signature deadpan line with a bizarre, unsettling fact that leaves everyone in awe. This kind of return would not only satisfy long-time fans but also help Criminal Minds regain the trust of its audience, especially after the underwhelming reception of Gubler’s first cameo.

While a permanent return might not be feasible, a guest appearance with a meaningful role could be the perfect bridge between the past and future of the show. It would allow fans to reconnect with Reid’s brilliance and remind the world why he was such an essential part of the BAU. With the right storyline and execution, Gubler’s return could be just what Criminal Minds: Evolution needs to rekindle the excitement and loyalty of its fanbase.