10 Oreo Flavors That Deserve a Comeback

The Unexpected History of Oreo Flavors

Oreos have become a global icon, but their journey to becoming the best-selling cookie in the world wasn't always smooth. Originally, they were a knock-off of Hydrox, another sandwich cookie that was introduced earlier. However, Nabisco's version eventually gained more popularity and became the standard we all know today. With over 100 years of history, Oreos are now sold in more than 100 countries and have been a staple with milk since the 1950s. While they've enjoyed massive success, not every flavor has had a long shelf life.

Despite this, Oreo has shown a pattern of bringing back some of its most beloved discontinued flavors. For example, the blueberry pie flavor made a comeback after being off the market for almost a decade. This trend gives fans hope that other retired flavors might also return. Below are 10 discontinued Oreo flavors that should definitely make a comeback, some of which may be among the best Oreo flavors ever created.

Red Velvet Oreo

Red velvet is a unique flavor that goes beyond just dyed chocolate cake. It has subtle notes of cocoa and is often paired with cream cheese frosting. The Red Velvet Oreo features cream cheese-flavored crème between two red cookies, offering a subtly sweet dessert. It first appeared in 2015 and was discontinued in 2020. However, it made a limited-time return in 2023, showing that fan persistence can lead to a revival.

PB&J Oreo

The PB&J (peanut butter and jelly) combination is a classic American favorite. Oreo released a limited edition PB&J flavor in 2017, using Golden Oreo cookies with a swirl of peanut butter and jelly flavored crème. It was designed to appeal to those who enjoyed PB&J sandwiches as a lunchtime staple. Despite positive feedback, the flavor was pulled from shelves and hasn’t returned since.

Fruity Crisp Oreo

Fruity Crisp Oreos, introduced in 2016, brought a cereal-like twist to the classic cookie. The golden crispy cookies featured thick crème with flecks of "colorful rice crisps." While not officially linked to Fruity Pebbles, the flavor was reminiscent of breakfast cereals. Fans loved the nostalgic taste, but the flavor eventually disappeared from store shelves.

Toasted Coconut Oreo

Toasted coconut evokes the warmth of the tropics. The Toasted Coconut Oreo, launched in 2015, paired Golden Oreo wafers with a smooth crème infused with toasted coconut. It offered a mellow yet distinctive flavor that many fans wished would remain on shelves permanently.

Cookie Butter Oreo

Cookie Butter Oreos, introduced in 2017, combined graham-flavored cookies with a cinnamon-tinged cookie butter crème. The flavor gave off a cozy, autumnal vibe and struck a perfect balance between sweet and spicy. Despite its popularity, the flavor didn't stay on shelves for long.

Firework Oreo

Firework Oreos added a playful twist with popping candy in the white filling. The texture created a fun experience that turned snack time into a mini celebration. Though it was initially a limited-edition release, it made a return in 2022 and is expected to come back again soon.

Watermelon Oreo

Watermelon Oreos, launched in 2013, were a bold experiment with a pastel pink and green crème that mimicked a watermelon slice. The flavor leaned more toward candy-sweet than fresh fruit, but it sparked curiosity and developed a cult following.

Rocky Road Trip Oreo

Rocky Road Trip Oreos took inspiration from the classic ice cream flavor, featuring chocolate cookies with marshmallow-infused crème and soy nuts. The texture was a standout, offering a mix of smooth and crisp. It was a popular limited-edition flavor that left fans wanting more.

Gingerbread Oreo

Gingerbread Oreos captured the cozy holiday vibes with spiced cookies and a crunchy pink sugar crystal filling. They became a popular seasonal treat, with periodic returns over the years. Fans still look forward to their annual appearance during the winter months.

Cookie Dough Oreo

Cookie Dough Oreos aimed to replicate the experience of eating raw cookie dough. The brown sugar-infused filling with tiny chocolate chips offered a buttery, slightly gritty texture. Although it was a limited-edition release, it remains a nostalgic favorite among fans.